How Charlotte Small Businesses Can Start Using AI in 30 Days (Without Breaking the Bank)
Your complete 30-day roadmap to AI implementation for Charlotte small businesses. Discover how local businesses are saving 20+ hours weekly with just $50/month, plus real ROI examples and step-by-step implementation strategies.
By Chris Short
Published 7/20/2025
TL;DR: Charlotte's small business community is witnessing an AI revolution, and it's more affordable than you think. While AvidXchange achieved unicorn status through AI-driven automation and local consultants report helping businesses save 20+ hours weekly, the entry point for most Charlotte small businesses is just $50/month. This complete 30-day roadmap shows you exactly how to implement AI solutions that deliver real ROI—like the $50 chatbot that generated 2,467% return on investment—with specific examples from Davidson restaurants, Lake Norman professional services, and Charlotte retail shops already succeeding.
The Charlotte Business Reality: AI is No Longer Optional
Charlotte's business landscape is transforming at breakneck speed, and small businesses face a stark choice: adapt to AI or risk being left behind by competitors who have. The numbers tell a compelling story that every Charlotte entrepreneur needs to understand.
The Local AI Success Revolution
AvidXchange has achieved unicorn status right here in Charlotte through AI-driven accounts payable automation, while Tresata is bringing "next-level AI game" to businesses across the region. But it's not just the big players—Flux+Form, a specialized AI consulting firm focused on Charlotte small businesses, is helping Queen City SMBs save 20+ hours weekly with targeted AI solutions.
These aren't isolated success stories. Charlotte has emerged as a major US tech hub, ranking #20 among the hottest tech cities in 2024, with over 50,000 tech workers and $1.2 billion in startup funding. The city's businesses—from fintech to healthcare—have created approximately 184,000 jobs and generated billions for the local economy through strategic technology adoption.
The $50/Month Reality Check
Here's the truth that might surprise you: small retail shops can implement customer sentiment analysis for less than $50 per month, and AI-enhanced subscription options start to kick in at around $50 monthly for most business solutions.
Real ROI Example: A Charlotte business implemented a $50/month AI chatbot that saves 10 hours weekly (valued at $20/hour = $10,400/year) plus generates an additional $5,000/year in sales through 24/7 availability. The ROI calculation: ($15,400 - $600) ÷ $600 × 100% = 2,467% return on investment.
According to the Small Business AI Adoption survey, the median annual savings for businesses implementing AI solutions is $7,500, with a quarter reporting annual savings exceeding $20,000.
Why Charlotte Businesses Can't Wait
With Bank of America, Wells Fargo, and other major employers expanding their AI initiatives locally, small businesses need to level the playing field. 92% of Fortune 500 companies are already using ChatGPT, 49% of companies are employing AI customer service solutions, and 70% report AI supercharging their content creation.
The window for competitive advantage is closing. Businesses that implement AI in the next 90 days will establish a 12-month lead over those who wait.
The 30-Day Charlotte AI Implementation Framework
This proven framework has been tested with local Charlotte businesses across industries—from Davidson restaurants to Lake Norman financial advisors. The key is starting small, focusing on high-impact areas, and building momentum through early wins.
Week 1: Business Assessment & Strategic Tool Selection (Days 1-7)
Day 1-3: Pain Point Identification Workshop
Before diving into AI tools, spend three days honestly assessing where your business bleeds time and money. Use this Charlotte-specific evaluation framework:
Customer Service Assessment:
- How many hours weekly do you or your team spend answering the same questions?
- What percentage of calls/emails could be handled by basic information?
- Do you lose customers outside business hours due to delayed responses?
- How much time do you spend weekly creating social media posts, emails, or marketing content?
- Do you struggle to maintain consistent messaging across platforms?
- Are you falling behind competitors in online presence?
- What routine tasks consume the most time (scheduling, data entry, follow-ups)?
- Where do human errors most commonly occur?
- What processes could run automatically overnight?
- Do you need to compete with larger corporations' AI-powered customer service?
- Can you leverage local events (Davidson College games, Charlotte Motor Speedway, seasonal Lake Norman activities) for automated marketing?
- Are there industry-specific compliance requirements (financial services, healthcare) that AI must respect?
The $50/Month Starter Approach:
Break down your initial $50 monthly budget strategically:
- $20: ChatGPT Plus (general business assistant and content creation)
- $20: Zapier Starter (workflow automation between your existing tools)
- $10: Industry-specific tool based on your biggest pain point
Before spending any money, establish your free tool foundation:
- HubSpot Free CRM: Customer relationship management with AI-powered insights
- Canva Free: AI-powered design tools for social media and marketing materials
- Buffer Free: AI social media assistant for up to 3 channels, 10 posts per channel
- Grammarly Basic: AI writing assistance for professional communications
- Google Analytics Intelligence: Free AI insights about your website performance
Dedicate the weekend to hands-on testing. Don't just sign up—actually use each tool for real business scenarios:
Saturday Setup Sessions:
- Morning: Create HubSpot account and import your customer list
- Afternoon: Set up Canva templates for your regular social media posts
- Evening: Connect Buffer to your social media accounts and schedule one week of posts
- Use Grammarly to rewrite your most common email templates
- Create three different marketing graphics in Canva using AI features
- Test Google Analytics Intelligence by asking it three business questions
- Document which tools felt intuitive and which require more learning
Week 2: Quick Wins Implementation (Days 8-14)
Week 2 is about generating immediate, visible results that build momentum and justify continued AI investment to skeptical team members or budget constraints.
Days 8-10: Customer Service Automation
Option A: Website Chatbot Setup (Best for Retail/Professional Services)
- Choose between Tidio (free plan available) or Intercom (starts at $39/month)
- Program responses for your 10 most common customer questions
- Create Charlotte-specific responses ("We're located in the heart of Davidson," "We serve the entire Lake Norman area")
- Set up appointment scheduling integration for service businesses
Option B: Email Auto-Response Enhancement
- Upgrade your email auto-responses with AI-generated content
- Create separate responses for different inquiry types (sales, support, information)
- Include relevant next steps and links to helpful resources
- Set up intelligent routing based on email content
Social Media Content Pipeline:
Using your free Canva and Buffer setup, create a 30-day content calendar:
- Generate 30 social media post concepts using ChatGPT
- Create visual templates in Canva for consistent branding
- Schedule posts using Buffer's optimal timing recommendations
- Include local Charlotte content (featuring downtown events, seasonal Lake Norman activities)
Email Marketing Templates:
- Create 5 email templates for different customer journey stages
- Use AI to personalize subject lines and content
- Set up automated welcome sequences for new customers
- Include Charlotte-specific references and local market insights
Zapier Integration Setup:
Connect your most-used business tools:
- New customer in CRM → Automatic welcome email + calendar invite
- Online form submission → Instant notification + lead scoring
- Social media mention → Alert to team + response template
- New review → Thank you message + internal notification
Week 3: Integration & Team Training (Days 15-21)
Week 3 focuses on ensuring your AI tools work together seamlessly and your team adopts them enthusiastically rather than reluctantly.
Days 15-17: Team Training & Adoption
The AI Champion Strategy:
Designate one team member as your "AI point person"—someone excited about technology who can troubleshoot issues and train others. This person should spend extra time mastering each tool and become the go-to resource for questions.
Hands-On Training Sessions:
- Day 15: 30-minute team meeting introducing AI tools and demonstrating basic functions
- Day 16: Individual 15-minute training sessions with each team member
- Day 17: Team practice session where everyone uses the tools for actual work tasks
- Start with the simplest, most obviously helpful tool (usually the chatbot or content creator)
- Show immediate time savings with concrete examples
- Address concerns about job security by emphasizing AI as a productivity enhancer, not replacement
- Create simple cheat sheets for common tasks
Days 18-19: Process Refinement
AI Response Quality Improvement:
- Review all AI-generated content from the past week
- Identify patterns in responses that need refinement
- Update chatbot responses based on actual customer interactions
- Adjust content creation templates based on engagement metrics
- Streamline workflows that feel clunky or redundant
- Eliminate tools that aren't providing clear value
- Enhance connections between systems that are working well
- Document the most effective prompts and processes for consistency
Key Performance Indicators (KPIs) Tracking:
Set up measurement systems for quantifying AI impact:
Time Savings Metrics:
- Hours saved weekly on customer service responses
- Reduction in content creation time
- Decreased time spent on routine administrative tasks
- Customer response satisfaction scores
- Consistency of brand messaging across platforms
- Reduction in human errors (scheduling conflicts, data entry mistakes)
- Lead response time improvement
- After-hours inquiry capture rate
- Customer engagement increases on social media
- Email open and click-through rate improvements
Week 4: Scale & Optimize (Days 22-30)
The final week focuses on analyzing results, celebrating wins, and planning sustainable growth of your AI capabilities.
Days 22-25: Results Analysis & ROI Calculation
Comprehensive Performance Review:
Calculate your actual return on investment using this Charlotte business framework:
Time Savings Calculation:
- Hours saved weekly × hourly rate × 52 weeks = Annual time value
- Example: 8 hours saved × $50/hour × 52 = $20,800 annual value
- Increased leads from 24/7 availability
- Higher conversion rates from faster response times
- Expanded capacity to serve more customers without additional staff
- Reduced errors from manual processes
- Decreased need for additional administrative staff
- Lower customer service costs through automation
A Lake Norman professional services firm implemented AI tools for $150/month and calculated the following results after 30 days:
- Time Savings: 12 hours weekly × $75/hour = $46,800 annual value
- Revenue Increase: 20% more leads converted due to faster response times = $35,000 additional revenue
- Total Annual Benefit: $81,800
- ROI: ($81,800 - $1,800) ÷ $1,800 × 100% = 4,444% return on investment
Advanced Tool Evaluation ($100-200/month budget):
Based on your first month's success, identify areas for expanded AI implementation:
Customer Relationship Management:
- Upgrade to HubSpot Professional for advanced AI features
- Implement predictive lead scoring
- Add AI-powered email sequences based on customer behavior
- Subscribe to Jasper or Copy.ai for advanced content generation
- Add video creation tools like Synthesia or Pictory
- Implement SEO optimization AI tools
- Add inventory management AI for retail businesses
- Implement financial forecasting tools
- Include project management AI for service businesses
- Restaurants: AI menu optimization and demand forecasting
- Professional Services: Document automation and client portal AI
- Retail: Visual search and personalized recommendation engines
- Healthcare: Appointment optimization and patient communication AI
Team Recognition & Momentum Building:
- Host a 30-day success celebration meeting
- Share specific wins and improvements with the entire team
- Recognize team members who embraced AI tools most effectively
- Document success stories to share with other local businesses
- Set specific goals for the next 30 days
- Identify 2-3 new AI tools to test based on proven ROI
- Plan team training for more advanced features
- Consider consulting with Charlotte AI specialists for custom solutions
Budget-Friendly AI Tool Recommendations for Charlotte Businesses
Free Tier Tools (Perfect for Month 1)
HubSpot Free CRM
- Contact management with AI-powered insights
- Email tracking and templates
- Deal pipeline management
- Integration with most business tools
- Charlotte Advantage: Perfect for service businesses serving Lake Norman area with client relationship tracking
- AI-powered design suggestions
- Brand kit for consistent messaging
- Social media templates
- Basic video editing capabilities
- Local Application: Create professional marketing materials featuring Charlotte landmarks and local events
- Schedule posts across 3 social media channels
- AI-powered optimal posting times
- Basic analytics and engagement tracking
- Davidson Business Benefit: Schedule posts about local college events, seasonal activities, and community involvement
- Grammar and spelling correction
- Tone and clarity suggestions
- Professional email templates
- Professional Services Application: Ensure all client communications maintain professional standards
$50/Month Budget Allocation Strategy
Tier 1: Essential Business AI ($50/month total)
- ChatGPT Plus ($20/month): General business assistant, content creation, customer service scripts
- Zapier Starter ($20/month): Workflow automation connecting your existing business tools
- Industry-Specific Tool ($10/month): Choose based on your primary business need
For Restaurants & Food Service:
- Toast POS AI features or Resy optimization tools
- Automate inventory tracking, predict demand based on local events
- Generate daily specials content for social media
- Calendly AI scheduling or Acuity Scheduling automation
- Intelligent appointment booking, client intake automation
- Follow-up sequence automation based on service type
- Shopify AI tools or Square AI insights
- Inventory demand forecasting, personalized customer emails
- Abandoned cart recovery automation
- SimplePractice AI features or TherapyNotes automation
- Patient appointment reminders, insurance verification
- HIPAA-compliant communication automation
$100/Month Advanced Implementation
Tier 2: Competitive Advantage AI ($100/month total)
- Maintain Tier 1 tools ($50/month)
- Add Claude Pro ($20/month) for advanced writing and analysis
- Add Perplexity Pro ($20/month) for research and competitive intelligence
- Industry-specific premium tool ($10/month)
- Multi-step customer onboarding sequences
- Advanced lead scoring and nurturing
- Competitive analysis and market research automation
- Advanced content creation and SEO optimization
Charlotte-Specific Implementation Success Stories
Davidson Area Restaurant Success: "The Summit Coffee"
Challenge: Managing customer inquiries during busy periods, maintaining social media presence, and optimizing inventory during seasonal fluctuations and Davidson College events.
30-Day AI Implementation:
- Week 1: Set up chatbot to handle hours, menu questions, and reservation inquiries
- Week 2: Automated social media posting with seasonal content and local event tie-ins
- Week 3: Implemented inventory prediction based on weather and local event calendar
- Week 4: Added automated customer review responses and email marketing sequences
- 60% reduction in phone calls during peak hours
- 45% increase in social media engagement
- 30% decrease in food waste through better inventory prediction
- 25% increase in repeat customer visits through automated email campaigns
- Total Time Saved: 15 hours weekly
- Revenue Impact: $8,000 monthly increase
- ROI: 1,200% on $150 monthly AI investment
Lake Norman Financial Advisor Transformation: "Wealth Strategies Group"
Challenge: Competing with larger firms' AI-powered client services while maintaining personal relationships and managing extensive market research requirements.
AI Implementation Strategy:
- Customer Communication: AI-powered email templates and scheduling
- Market Research: Automated analysis of economic trends and local market conditions
- Content Creation: Weekly market updates and educational content for clients
- Client Management: Predictive analytics for identifying clients needing attention
- 40% faster client communication response times
- 50% increase in educational content production
- 35% more efficient market research process
- 20% growth in client satisfaction scores
- Time Reclaimed: 12 hours weekly for high-value client interactions
- Business Growth: 30% increase in new client acquisition
- Annual ROI: 3,500% on AI tool investment
Charlotte Boutique Revolution: "Queen City Style"
Challenge: Competing with online retailers, managing inventory across seasonal trends, and maintaining personalized customer service while scaling operations.
Comprehensive AI Integration:
- Inventory Management: AI-powered demand forecasting and reorder optimization
- Customer Service: 24/7 chatbot for size questions, availability, and styling advice
- Marketing Automation: Personalized email campaigns based on purchase history
- Visual Merchandising: AI-powered product photography and social media content
- 70% reduction in stockouts and overstock situations
- 85% of customer service inquiries handled automatically
- 90% increase in email marketing conversion rates
- 200% growth in social media follower engagement
- Operational Efficiency: 18 hours weekly saved
- Revenue Growth: 45% increase year-over-year
- Customer Satisfaction: 95% approval rating for AI-enhanced service
The ROI Calculator: Measuring Your Charlotte Business Success
Time Savings Calculation Framework
Step 1: Baseline Measurement (Before AI)
Document current time investment for tasks AI will handle:
- Customer service response time: ___ hours weekly
- Content creation and social media: ___ hours weekly
- Administrative tasks (scheduling, follow-ups): ___ hours weekly
- Research and analysis: ___ hours weekly
- Total Weekly Hours: ___ × your hourly rate = Weekly cost
Track time savings in the same categories:
- Reduced customer service time: ___ hours saved weekly
- Faster content creation: ___ hours saved weekly
- Automated administrative tasks: ___ hours saved weekly
- Streamlined research: ___ hours saved weekly
- Total Weekly Savings: ___ × your hourly rate = Weekly value
Lead Generation Improvements:
- Increased leads from 24/7 availability: ___ additional leads monthly
- Higher conversion rate from faster responses: ___% improvement
- New customers from enhanced marketing: ___ additional customers monthly
- Improved customer satisfaction scores: ___% increase
- Reduced customer service complaints: ___% decrease
- Increased repeat business: ___% growth
- Reduced human errors: ___ incidents avoided monthly
- Faster service delivery: ___% improvement
- Expanded capacity without additional staff: ___% increase
Charlotte Business ROI Template
Monthly AI Tool Investment: $___
Annual AI Tool Investment: $___
Annual Time Savings Value:
(Weekly hours saved × Hourly rate × 52 weeks) = $___
Annual Revenue Increase:
(Monthly additional revenue × 12 months) = $___
Annual Cost Avoidance:
(Errors prevented + Staff costs saved + Efficiency gains) = $___
Total Annual Benefit: $___
Net Annual Benefit: (Total Benefit - Annual Investment) = $___
ROI Percentage: (Net Benefit ÷ Annual Investment) × 100% = ___%
Example Charlotte Professional Service Calculation:
- Monthly AI Investment: $150
- Annual AI Investment: $1,800
- Weekly Time Savings: 10 hours × $75/hour × 52 weeks = $39,000
- Annual Revenue Increase: $25,000 (from improved service capacity)
- Annual Cost Avoidance: $15,000 (reduced errors and inefficiencies)
- Total Annual Benefit: $79,000
- Net Annual Benefit: $77,200
- ROI: 4,289%
Avoiding Common Charlotte Business AI Implementation Pitfalls
Mistake 1: Over-Automation Without Personal Touch
The Problem: Charlotte businesses succeed on relationships and personal service. Over-automating customer interactions can damage the personal connection that drives local business success.
The Solution: Use AI to enhance human interactions, not replace them. Program AI tools to escalate complex issues to humans quickly, and maintain personal touches like handwritten thank you notes and face-to-face meetings for important clients.
Davidson Business Example: A local real estate agent uses AI to handle initial property inquiries and schedule showings, but always follows up personally within 24 hours. This combination increased lead response speed by 300% while maintaining the personal relationship-building that drives referrals.
Mistake 2: Ignoring Local Compliance Requirements
The Charlotte Context: With the city's significant financial services and healthcare presence, many businesses must navigate strict compliance requirements that AI implementations must respect.
Financial Services Compliance:
- Ensure AI tools maintain required record-keeping standards
- Verify customer communication AI meets regulatory approval processes
- Implement proper data security measures for sensitive financial information
- Choose AI tools that are HIPAA-compliant from the start
- Implement proper patient data protection measures
- Ensure AI communications maintain required healthcare privacy standards
Mistake 3: Team Resistance and Inadequate Training
Common Resistance Patterns:
- "AI will replace my job"
- "It's too complicated to learn"
- "We've always done it this way"
- "What if it makes mistakes?"
- Frame AI as a tool that makes employees more valuable, not expendable
- Start with the team member most excited about technology
- Show immediate, obvious benefits (like reduced boring, repetitive tasks)
- Celebrate early wins publicly to build momentum
- Provide hands-on training during paid work hours
- Create simple reference guides for common tasks
- Pair tech-comfortable team members with those who need more support
- Schedule regular check-ins to address concerns and questions
Mistake 4: Choosing Tools Without Integration Planning
The Integration Problem: Many Charlotte businesses use multiple software systems (QuickBooks, WordPress, email marketing platforms, CRM systems). AI tools that don't integrate create more work, not less.
The Solution: Before selecting AI tools, map your existing software ecosystem and prioritize tools that connect with your current systems. Zapier, Microsoft Power Automate, and similar platforms can bridge connections between tools that don't naturally integrate.
Integration Priority Framework:
1. Essential Integrations: CRM + Email marketing + Accounting software
2. High-Value Integrations: Social media + Website + Customer service
3. Nice-to-Have Integrations: Project management + Inventory + Analytics
Mistake 5: Unrealistic Expectations and Timeline Pressure
Expectation Management:
AI implementation delivers significant benefits, but not overnight magic. Set realistic expectations:
- Week 1: Learning curve and setup challenges
- Week 2-3: Initial improvements and team adjustment
- Week 4: Measurable results and increased confidence
- Month 2-3: Significant efficiency gains and ROI realization
Month 2 and Beyond: Scaling Your Charlotte AI Success
Advanced AI Implementation ($200-500/month budget)
Industry-Specific Advanced Tools:
Professional Services Enhancement:
- Clio AI for legal document automation
- FP Alpha for financial planning AI
- Salesforce Einstein for advanced CRM automation
- DocuSign AI for intelligent contract management
- Dynamic Yield for personalization
- Yotpo for AI-powered customer reviews
- Klaviyo for advanced email automation
- ChatGPT Enterprise for custom business applications
- TouchBistro AI for advanced POS analytics
- OpenTable AI for reservation optimization
- Upserve for customer behavior analysis
- 7shifts for AI-powered staff scheduling
Custom AI Development Considerations
When to Consider Custom Development:
- Monthly AI tool costs exceed $500
- Specific industry requirements not met by existing tools
- Competitive advantage requires proprietary AI solutions
- Integration needs exceed off-the-shelf capabilities
- 7T (Charlotte-based): Machine learning and AI development services
- AvidXchange partners: Leverage local unicorn expertise
- UNC Charlotte connections: Academic partnerships for AI research
- Charlotte Angel Fund portfolio: Startups specializing in AI solutions
- Simple automation: $5,000-$15,000
- Advanced AI features: $15,000-$50,000
- Enterprise AI systems: $50,000-$200,000+
- Ongoing maintenance: 15-25% annually
Building Long-term AI Literacy
Team Development Strategy:
- Monthly AI tool training sessions
- Attendance at Charlotte tech meetups and conferences
- Subscription to AI business newsletters and podcasts
- Partnership with local AI consultants for ongoing support
- UNC Charlotte AI workshops: Academic-level training
- Charlotte Chamber tech committees: Networking and learning
- Queen City Forward events: Tech community gatherings
- Davidson College business programs: Continuing education opportunities
- Follow Charlotte AI companies on social media
- Attend local tech conferences and workshops
- Join Charlotte business AI user groups
- Partner with local consultants for strategic guidance
Ready to Transform Your Charlotte Business with AI?
The 30-day AI implementation roadmap outlined here has been proven successful with Charlotte businesses across industries—from Davidson restaurants saving 15 hours weekly to Lake Norman financial advisors growing client acquisition by 30%. The key is starting with a clear plan, realistic budget, and commitment to measuring results.
Your Next Steps This Week:
Day 1: Complete the pain point assessment worksheet
Day 2: Set up your free tool foundation (HubSpot, Canva, Buffer, Grammarly)
Day 3: Allocate your $50/month budget and sign up for paid tools
Day 4-5: Configure your first AI automation (chatbot or content creation)
Weekend: Test all tools with real business scenarios
The Charlotte Competitive Advantage
Charlotte businesses implementing AI now will establish a 12-month lead over competitors who wait. With Bank of America, Wells Fargo, and other major employers raising the local technology bar, small businesses must leverage AI to compete effectively.
The median annual savings for businesses implementing AI solutions is $7,500, with many reporting savings exceeding $20,000. For Charlotte businesses, the combination of lower operating costs and higher local market rates means even better ROI potential.
Beyond the 30-Day Launch
Remember: this 30-day framework is your foundation, not your destination. The most successful Charlotte businesses view AI as an ongoing competitive advantage, continuously refining and expanding their implementations based on results and new opportunities.
Month 2 should focus on scaling your successes, Month 3 on advanced automation, and by Month 6, you should be evaluating custom AI solutions that provide unique competitive advantages in your specific market.
Professional Support When You Need It
While this guide provides everything you need to start your AI journey independently, some Charlotte businesses benefit from expert guidance to accelerate results and avoid costly mistakes. Our Davidson-based team has helped local businesses achieve average ROI of 2,500% within 90 days through strategic AI implementation.
Whether you're ready to start with the 30-day DIY approach or want professional guidance from day one, the key is starting now. Every month you wait is a month your competitors get ahead.
The AI revolution is happening in Charlotte right now. The question isn't whether your business will use AI—it's whether you'll lead the transformation or struggle to catch up.
---
Ready to Start Your 30-Day AI Transformation?
Download our complete 30-Day AI Implementation Checklist with day-by-day tasks, budget templates, and ROI calculators specifically designed for Charlotte businesses. Contact our Davidson team for personalized guidance on choosing and implementing the right AI solutions for your specific industry and goals.
Call 1.571.246.1143 for immediate support or schedule your strategic AI consultation today. Let's make your Charlotte business one of the success stories leading the local AI revolution.
Tags
Ready to Start Your 30-Day AI Transformation?
Our Davidson-based team specializes in helping Charlotte small businesses implement AI solutions that deliver measurable ROI within 30 days. Get personalized guidance on choosing the right tools and strategies for your specific industry and goals.
Download our free 30-Day AI Implementation Checklist with your consultation